Formative Evaluation of Teachers’ Performance

Published in EduLeader - August 2019

Teacher evaluation might lead to counterproductive results if conducted in a manner that declines their status as professionals. Therefore, it should focus on the growth of teachers’ knowledge, viewpoints and inquiries. For this, evaluation must be conceived as a formative process aiming at the growth and improvement of teachers’ performance. Teachers, thus, need to be provided room to examine their practices and those of others they work with. Reflection helps teachers do so and develops their analytical skills of their practices and moves them closer toward autonomy (Robbins & Alvy, 2014). In addition, peers can take part in teachers’ evaluations which reduces the stress caused when the administration or personnel in supervisory positions (Acheson & Gall, 2011) are the sole evaluators of teachers’ performance. Learning walks that involve peers and peer visits are excellent ways to collect data on teachers’ performance and to provide them with formative feedback in low stress situations and in a collegial manner, all of which are conducive to creating positive interdependent communities at schools. At times, it might be helpful to invite external observers to conduct learning walks or classroom observations to provide teachers with data from an outside source.

Interdependent communities are enhanced when teachers are active participants in developing their own evaluation system, and the evaluation system will become more reflective of their concerns (Sergiovanni & Starrot, 2006). In doing so, the evaluation criteria become clear for the teachers, which is only fair in the process of helping them, especially novice ones, grow and develop in their careers and to boost their confidence and abilities.

Other formative methods for teacher evaluation can include portfolio complication by teachers. Portfolios are of special importance, for they allow teachers to document their growth in a visible manner. Lesson plans, evidence on implementation of new or successful practices, reflection reports, checklists and observation reports can be among the components of teacher-compiled portfolios.

Students are a good source of data for teachers’ formative evaluation. Students can provide their perceptions on how they view the practices in their classrooms. This helps clarify to teachers the impact of classroom happenings on students’ perceptions. Interviewing students or having them complete questionnaires are ways to collect data that can be shared with teachers, or better yet, teachers themselves can collect this data from their students.

Teachers keeping a checklist at hand can enhance self-monitoring. Such checklists might include practices that the school considers essential. Newly introduced practices or activities can be included in the checklists. Coaches or subject coordinators can encourage teachers to refer to these checklists periodically. This will remind teachers of these essential practices and will help them monitor how often they are implementing them.

Although summative evaluation of teacher performance is necessary for administrative purposes, it is only fair that it be conducted after a long process of formative evaluation that aims at bringing teachers as close as possible to the desired outcomes. This formative evaluation must be collegial, respectful of teachers’ opinions and knowledge and goal-oriented. All in all, it should allow teachers to grow as professionals and become autonomous learners and problem solvers.

References

Acheson, K. A., & Gall, M. D. (2011). Clinical Supervision and Teacher Development: Preservice and Inservice Applications (6 ed.). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

Robbins, P., & Alvy, H. B. (2014). The Principal's Companion: Strategies and Hints to Make the Job Easier. Thousand Oaks: Corwin Press.

Sergiovanni, T., & Starrot, R. (2006). Supervision: A Redefinition (8 ed.). New York: Mc Graw Hill.

Learn, Grow, Inspire… and Be Inspired!

     Opening message in Al Mada yearbook - Summer 2019

It has been a very exciting academic year for all of us at Rawafid. Just when I thought we could safely say that a professional learning community has been established at our school, I realized there were more horizons for us to explore. That is where our new learning takes place, and that is where the magic happens!

Looking back at the past year, there is so much to celebrate. Our continuous growth and our success stories, story after another, bring joy and a sense of pride to the teachers and students alike and to the Rawafid community at large. This year was marked by the integration of many principles in teaching. Creating a positive spirit in the school, turning learning into social events, individualizing instruction, and trusting the learners are a few of the principles teachers and coaches have diligently worked on implementing in their practices. This implementation is evident for the observer in both the classroom and the playground.

Adopting new practices was always preceded by training. This was followed by reflecting on practices in order to evaluate and refine them. Planning for action came after reflecting, and all taking place in a cyclic process where each cycle fed into another. This goes hand in hand with the theory of experiential learning that we passionately believe in. Coaching rather than supervising was a vital practice that facilitated the process and transformed Rawafid’s students, teachers and administrators into a community of learners. One of the outcomes of coaching is reflected in hearing teachers willingly inviting colleagues to attend their classrooms to observe new activities being tried out.  

All in all, I can’t but feel proud of how far we have come at Rawafid. Of course, there are still many more horizons to seek, which we will reach and explore with enthusiasm, dedication, love to discover and willingness to surpass ourselves.

Thus, we, staff and students, will continue to learn, grow, achieve, inspire,
and be inspired!

Theories and Tenets That Are Vital in Implementing a Professional Development Plan at School

Article published in The EduLEADER

July 2019

Implementing a professional development plan at a school requires careful planning and basing practices on grounded theories and tenets in the field. Often, the personnel involved in professional development find that what applies to teacher education intersects with what applies to student learning. Here, I choose several practices and theories that have worked well when I worked with groups of teachers.

Experiential learning and the practice cycle

Kolb’s model of learning (Kolb & Kolb, 2005) aims at transforming schools through reflective observation and experimentation in a four stage-cycle of:

·         concrete experience when lesson observation takes place to collect evidence to be used in the   feedback session

·         reflective observation which is based on the evidence collected, and feedbacking occurs here to assist the teacher to reflect on practice

·         abstract conceptualization which includes encouraging teachers to discuss the deep structures of teaching to establish theoretical principles that undergo the observed behaviors

·        active experimentation in which the discussion of principles is derived from the lesson to decide how to apply them in a new situation.

This cycle goes parallel to Randall and Thornton’s (2005) practice cycle which they perceive also as a helping cycle including the phases: exploration, understanding (combines the abstract conceptualization and active experimentation phases in Kolb’s model) and action.  

The underlying concepts and the practices for experiential learning and the practice cycle are evident in many other models such as Korthagen’s ALACT model (action, looking back on the action, awareness of essential aspects, creating alternative methods of action and trial), Cogan’s eight-stage clinical supervision, and Wallace’s six-phase HORACE pattern (Hear, observe, record, analyze, consider, evaluate) (Farhat, 2011).

Collaboration and interaction

Collaboration is empowering for teachers if it allows them to increase their knowledge and to be actively involved in shaping the school culture (Glazer & Hannafin, 2006). Collaboration allows teachers to pool their resources toward the attainment of a common goal if it is done in a context of communication, trust and flexibility and responsiveness to change (Mackenzie, Zakrzewski, Walker, & McCluskey, 2008).

Collaboration allows teachers to consider themselves as leaders, for while collaborating they are participating in leadership (Lambert, 2003). This is empowering for teachers. The power of collaboration is echoed by Michael Fullan (2008) who sees that it should be positive and purposeful to achieve optimal results.

Peer coaching and peer mentoring

In a coach-teacher relationship, the coach facilitates the teacher’s thinking and helps him/her learn on the job (Miller, 2018). Here the coach is in charge of the process of having the teachers achieve a certain goal. This form of peer supervision diminishes bureaucracy from supervision since it allows teachers to work in teams, develop their own plans, share ideas, have face to face feedback, and analyze results (Marshal, 2005). Further, these practices allow teachers to have more choice, to reflect, to network, to break down the silence that teachers live, and to generate their own solutions, all of which are vital to improve practices in education (Potgieter, 2019).

“A variation of peer coaching is peer mentoring where an experienced teacher and a less experienced one form a relationship” (Farhat, 2017, p. 57). However, mentors advise based on their personal experiences. Here, the teacher is the owner of the goals and the process. Both practices, coaching and mentoring, are low cost and are proven to be conducive to professional development of teachers (Farhat, 2017).

Professional learning communities

The concept of professional learning communities has been evolving since 1989 starting with Rosenholtz, and since then several models have emerged to depict what a professional learning community is (Hassan, Ahmad , & Boon, 2018). Whatever model is considered, the professional learning community is a practice that enhances teacher collaboration and reflection which gradually facilitates the creation of a common vision and norms among teachers. All this is for the optimal goal which is student learning (Avalos, 2011). Improved student outcome is observed “in terms of achievement, social skills, emotional aspects, independence and creativity” as a study by Owen revealed through “achievement data, student work samples, teacher observation and self-reports” (Owen, 2015, p. 57).

For the school to be a professional learning community, administrators, teachers and students must be involved in responsibility and its underlying actions (Sergiovanni & Starratt, 2006). Further, the community and parents can take part in this community by providing their ideas and feedback. In this way, the school vision will be embraced by all (Hassan, Ahmad , & Boon, 2018).

A common thread passes among all the above-mentioned practices. They all subsume interaction, collaboration, sharing, scaffolding and support to reach a specific goal. Just as these practices have proven to be successful in classroom practices, they are also vital when adult learning is involved.

References

Avalos, B. (2011). Teacher professional development in teaching and teacher education over ten years. Teachign and Teacher Education(27), 10-20.

Farhat, A. (2011). The Impact of Clinical Supervision on Teachers' Performance in Classroom Managerial Skills. Beirut, Lebanon: Lebanese University.

Farhat, A. (2017). The perceptions of English language teachers and supervisors of supervisory practices. Beirut, Lebanon: Lebanese University.

Fullan, M. (2008). The Six Secrets of Change. San Francisco, California, USA: Jossey-Bass.

Glazer, E., & Hannafin, M. (2006). The collaborative appernticeship model: Situated professionl development with school settings. Teaching and Teacher Education, 22(2), 179-193.

Hassan, R., Ahmad , j., & Boon, Y. (2018). Professional Learning Communities in Malaysia. International Journal of Engineering and Teaching, 7(30), 433-443. doi:10.14419/ijet.v7i3.30.18347

Kolb, A. Y., & Kolb, D. A. (2005). Learning Styles and Learning Spaces: Enhancing Experiential Learning in Higher Education. Academy of Management Learning and Education, 4(2), 193-212.

Lambert, L. (2003). Leadership redefined: an evocative cotnext for teacher leadership. School Leadership and Management, 23(4), 421-430.

Mackenzie, L., Zakrzewski, L., Walker, C., & McCluskey, A. (2008). Meeting the educational needs of fieldwork superivosrs: A collaboarative workhsop developed by New South Wales occupational therapy fieldword coordinators. Australian Occupational Therapy Journal, 1-10. doi:https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1440-1630.2001.00233.x

Marshal, K. (2005, June). It's time to rethink teacher supervision and evaluation. Phi Delta Kappan, 86(10), 727-735. doi:https://doi.org/10.1177/003172170508601004

Miller, J. (2018, 8 30). 14 Coaching Principles All Managers Should Practise. Retrieved 7 10, 2019, from Leaderonomics: https://leaderonomics.com/leadership/coaching-principles-managers-should-practise

Owen, S. (2015). Teacher professional learnign communities in innovative contexts: 'ah hah moments', 'passion' and 'making a difference' for student learning. Professional Development in Education, 41(1), 57-74. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/19415257.2013.869504

Potgieter, E. (2019, 7 10). Transforming Malaysia's Education System. The Bigger Picture . (K. Anissa, Interviewer) Retrieved 7 10, 2019, from https://www.bfm.my/podcast/the-bigger-picture/live-learn/transforming-malaysia-education-system

Randall , M., & Thornton, B. (2005). Advising and Supporting Teachers. (M. Williams, & T. Wright, Eds.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Sergiovanni, T., & Starratt, R. (2006). Supervision: A Redefinition (8 ed.). New York: McGraw Hill.

iatefl - Liverpool 2019

The 53 International IATEFL Conference 

 IATEFL conference is one of the main events in the English language teaching worldwide. Attending it once is enough to make this event an addiction.. This year it was attended by around 3000 professionals in the English language teaching and included about 500 talks, workshops and forums.  

Conference Venue - ACC

I had the opportunity to present this year in one of the conference's special interest groups: Leadership and Management SIG. My presentation, titled "Transforming a School into a Learning Community through Distributing Leadership" was placed in the SIG's showcased papers. 

Abstract

This presentation outlines the journey taken by an educational consultant in a school to distribute leadership among teachers so that each has a leadership role. This model can inspire similar professional development plans that can be tailored to the needs of different schools where everyone is empowered and the school culture is transformed into a culture of co-learning.

Summary:

This presentation shows how one small private school implemented a professional development program that involved its teachers in school leadership tasks, each based on his/her strengths, skills, certification and/or desire. This has been going on for the third consecutive academic year.

Implementation started with meetings with the administration and the subject coordinators to make an inventory of the professional needs of the teachers. This was coupled with eliciting teachers’ opinions on what they believed they needed assistance with through a Google Form questionnaire. Then the school launched a professional development center to cater for the logistics of training and professional development events. Themes to be worked on were

decided on and teachers from the school and experts from outside the school were contacted to carry out facilitation sessions for the different themes.

Themes included: basic theories and concepts in teaching, technology literacy, interactive technology, methods of teaching, classroom management, engaging activities, lesson planning, school publications, … For each theme, the teachers were grouped and each group had a coach. Groups met periodically to review the new concepts they learned and to discuss the challenges and merits of

their newly acquired skills. They also reflected on their practices and how they changed.

Tools used to ensure the sustainability of the new learnings: meetings, facilitating training

sessions, classroom observations, peer visits, checklists, reflection, on-going assessment, mentoring …

Finally, the presentation will show sample of outcome of the professional development program

as shown by observations, reflections and testimonies of teachers and coaches.

___________________________________________

It was a great opportunity to meet with writers, theorists, exhibitors and professionals in ELT.

With author of books on methodology and coursebooks, Lindsay Clandfield

With Scott Thornbury, an internationally recognized linguist, academic and author

With the internationally recognized linguist, author and academic David Crystal

Although attending the conference is enriching and allows for keeping up-to-date on what's new in ELT worldwide, it is great friends who make this event special and enjoyable.  

Great friends who also presented important papers: Rasha (learner autonomy) and Maysaa (integrating technology into writing)

Using EduLead Practices to Implement FIRST Framework

Published in EduLead Newsletter - May 2019

     The FIRST framework by SEGA Group is “designed on the basis of renown models and theories, such as experiential learning; gamification and game-based learning; facilitate learning, 6Ds model, positive psychology, experience economy and neuroscience” (Bahgat, Said, Elsafty, & Shaarawy, 2018, p. 123). These models and theories are framed into five domains and 15 principles. In implementing FIRST in Rawafid School*, we integrated it into a leadership framework, in which many of the concepts and practices are derived from the EduLead program, by Rite Education.

     Implementation went as follows: Each month one of the five domains with its three principles were introduced to the teachers via two of the school teachers who had been trained and certified by the founders of the FIRST Framework. This training session was followed by classroom implementation on the part of the teachers. It is important to note here that teachers were grouped into 5 groups, each led by a coach. Coaches were assigned this role based on the delegation matrix  (RITE International Inc., 2018), where teachers who portray skill and experience on one axis and independence and ability to drive-self on the second axis, were selected to coach groups.

      During implementation, learning walks were conducted by peers (a group member and the coach) focusing on the principles that were the subject of the training sessions. Learning walks observation forms were tailored to include the principles of the domain teachers were trained on. Those observation forms were accumulating with new principles as we proceeded in the program throughout the school year.

     After the implementation and learning walks, the groups of teachers and their coaches conducted PLC meetings where they reviewed the principles and the activities that would serve each of the principles and discussed their practices: what went well, what challenges they faced and how they would overcome them.

     This cycle was repeated 5 times, once for each of the FIRST domains. During this implementation, teachers kept learning portfolios to document their practices and their learnings. The portfolios included lesson plans, reflection logs, evidence of implementation, and checklists for self-evaluation.

     In addition, there was an online quiz that served to motivate teachers to review the principles and to monitor where teachers still needed help.

     Finally, summative evaluation was conducted where whole classroom observations were done; each teacher was observed by one of the coaches and another peer. Observation notes were compared and discussed by the observers. Then they were discussed with the teacher whose classroom was observed. In addition, teachers planned whole lessons integrating the FIRST domains. Lessons were uploaded to Google Drive, reviewed by the coaches, including the trainers and the educational supervisor at the school. Detailed feedback was provided to the teachers.

     All in all, implementation of FIRST Framework within a Leadership framework enhanced implementation and allowed for continuous reflection on practice and planning for action. Further, it has been a great stepping stone to transfer the whole school into a professional learning community where all learn from one another. In this leadership framework, different responsibilities such as training, coaching and peer visits, were delegated to different teachers. This helped distribute leadership among different teachers; a practice that makes them more engaged in their learning and more accountable for the program success. In addition, it makes the teachers the owners of the process of their growth and development.

*located in Bekaa, Lebanon

References

Bahgat, M., Said, T., Elsafty, A., & Shaarawy, A. (2018, August). FIRST Framework Design and Facilitate Active Deep Learner eXperience. Journal of Education and Training Studies, 6(8). doi:10.11114/jets.v6i8.3337

RITE International Inc. (2018). Kuala Lumpur: NAMA Foundation.

تجربة الروافد في برامج الدعم المدرسي + التعلم بالمشاريع

 الروافد في مؤتمر تربوي بألانيا التركية

Alanya Aladdin Keykubat University - 

شارك مدير مدرسة الروافد الأستاذ سامي الخطيب ترافقه المشرفة التربوية الدكتورة آمال فرحات في المؤتمر العلمي الدولي الأول للعلوم الإنسانية "نظرة نحو المستقبل" الذي نظمته على مدى ثلاثة أيام (13و14و15 نيسان 2018) مؤسسة بابير بالتعاون مع جامعة ألانيا علاء الدين كيكوبات الحكومية في مدينة ألانيا التركية بمشاركة خمسمائة باحث وباحثة من ثمانٍ وعشرين دولة عربية وغربية.

وقد قدَّم الأستاذ سامي الخطيب ورقة بعنوان: "برامج الدعم المدرسي ودورها في ردم الهوَّة بين متطلبات المنهج وواقع التلميذ: قراءة في تجربة مدرسة الروافد".

كما قدمت المشرفة التربوية في مدرسة الروافد الدكتورة آمال فرحات ورقة تربوية حول التعلم بالمشاريع بعنوان: "Bridging the Gap in the Curriculum Through Project-Based Learning

وقد كان المؤتمر فرصة لإطلاع المشاركين على تجارب مدرستنا، وللتعرُّف إلى الكثير من التجارب المدرسية الغنية وبناء العلاقات التربوية المفيدة.

وفي نهاية المؤتمر قدَّم مدير جامعة ألانيا الدكتور أحمد بينار باشي درعاً تكريمياً لمدير الروافد تقديراً لدوره في إنجاح المؤتم

Strive, Inspire, Achieve..

My opening message for Al Mada yearbook  - Summer 2018

This year, I watched with great joy our students enjoying their achievements and their ever-growing skills. I could feel that everyone else at Rawafid shared the same joy; teachers, administrators and staff. Rawafid students demonstrated advancement in their leadership skills, critical thinking abilities, autonomy and communication skills. These were evident in the many curricular and extra-curricular activities that took place during the academic year. The Rawafid Science Fair, student elections, charity campaigns, and the many competitions whether in school or among other schools were some of the events where students exercised their higher-order thinking skills and their leadership and communication skills.

All this would not have been possible and successful if Rawafid did not function as a community of professionals. Everyone at Rawafid was actively engaged in making the school a community of growth and progress, a community when all are supportive of one another. In our community, teachers are continuously thriving to improve their skills and increase their knowledge. This has been evident in the professional development program which focused this year on interactive learning. Teachers showed perseverance and passion to improve their skills which highly reflected on the classroom dynamics. In addition, students reported that they enjoyed learning more and the achievement of many increased.

Part of the professional development this year was the participation of two English language teachers in seven-day rigorous professional training program in Malaysia followed by one-year on-going online training. The teachers had to pass on their training to the Rawafid teachers through workshops facilitated at school.

The achievements of one at Rawafid become the achievements of all and the joy of the whole school. These achievements do not come without planning and hard work.

So go ahead, Rawafid staff and students, enjoy your achievements and your plans,

keep striving for the heights

and stay inspired and inspire those in your life.

June 2018